Exhibitor Press Releases
Data centre cooling: why process and proof matter
Two elements are critical in reducing risk:
1)
A design process based on
accurate performance data
2)
The factory witness test – a procedure
used to verify performance before equipment ever reaches site.
This article explores the cooling equipment
selection process for data centres, the importance of the factory witness test
and the role of product certification in reducing risk of project delays, spiralling
costs and future system problems.
Unlike comfort cooling applications, data
centre HVAC systems must support mission-critical infrastructure. Additionally,
the demand for data centres outstrips the speed at which they can be built, meaning
that any delays in construction programmes can have serious financial
penalties. Therefore, when it comes to specifying cooling equipment, data
centre operators are not just choosing a product, they are choosing a partner. As
a result, the supply process needs to be rigorous, transparent and seamlessly aligned
with operational requirements from the outset.
The process usually begins with a clear
definition of the data centre’s needs, including:
- IT load and heat density
- Redundancy strategy (e.g. N, N+1,
2N)
- Environmental conditions and
allowable temperature bands
- Power Usage Effectiveness
(PUE) targets and sustainability goals
- Failure scenarios
- System type e.g. CRAC, CRAH with chilled water, free cooling, liquid cooling, etc.
- Planning and compliance considerations
- Plus, any location and infrastructure constraints.
An SLA (Service Level Agreement) is used to
define Data Centre performance. SLAs are incredibly strict and failure to meet
them incurs huge financial consequences. Any ambiguity in requirements at this
stage increases the risk of performance shortfalls later.
Once operational requirements are defined,
they must be translated into precise technical specifications for HVACR
equipment. This may include:
- Cooling capacity under
realistic operating conditions over 365 days a year performance
- Peak and part-load performance
(with the required redundancy and resilience)
- Airflow and control strategies
- Pipework requirements
- Integration with monitoring and
control systems
- Acoustic and spatial
constraints.
Manufacturers respond with proposed
solutions, which are likely to incorporate detailed pre-procurement and
technical information such as data sheets, selection sheets, piping and
instrumentation diagrams (P&IDs), general arrangement (GA) drawings, control
sequences, installation and operation manuals (IOM), and integration details
for BMS and EPMS.
For data centre operators, this
pre-procurement stage is critical. It is often the final opportunity to
validate that performance data, assumptions and interfaces are fully understood
before contractual commitments are made. Manufacturer performance claims must
be based on verified, independently supported data rather than theoretical or
best-case values, as any inaccuracies at this stage can directly affect
equipment selection, system design, project cost and long-term operational
resilience.
Next the design team, procurement team and
client will review the manufacturer offer for compliance with the specification
(capacity, redundancy, ambient range, footprint, acoustics, efficiency,
codes/standards etc.). Clarifications and revisions are common during this
phase to ensure technical and contractual alignment.
Once product selection has been confirmed
and procurement approval granted, the manufacturer will proceed with building
the equipment. Before shipment, the products will usually undergo a Factory
Witness Test (FWT) to verify that the supplied units meet the agreed technical
and performance requirements prior to delivery to site.
The factory witness test
Factory witness testing allows operators,
consultants and stakeholders to observe and verify equipment performance under
controlled conditions before delivery. For data centres, this step is
increasingly seen as essential rather than an optional extra.
FWTs involve testing HVAC equipment at the
manufacturer’s facility, while representatives from the client or an
independent body witness the process on the client’s behalf. It will also usually
include a review of all drawings, P&IDs, wiring diagrams, control
sequences, and test procedures against the specification. The goal is to
confirm that the unit:
- Meets specified performance
criteria
- Operates as expected across
defined load conditions
- Behaves as expected during
start up, shutdown and simulated fault conditions
- Passes all safety checks
- Functions correctly before installation and commissioning.
If the unit fails to match the performance on the selection sheet, three things will happen:
- Investigations must take place
- The issue must be resolved
- The unit must be retested.
Depending on the issue and ease of remedy,
this can take weeks to months to complete, delaying the construction programme.
While the financial implications can be severe, a worse consequence is loss of
credibility - especially in a market where partnership and confidence are key.
The FWT is vital as once HVAC equipment is installed in a live data centre, correcting performance issues can be very costly and disruptive. The FWT shifts this risk upstream by identifying potential problems early, such as:
- Capacity shortfalls
- Control or sequencing issues
- Deviations from declared performance
- Component or assembly issues.
For data centre operators, this reduces the
likelihood of late-stage surprises. However, catching issues early will still
cause headaches in the short term. A failed factory witness test will have
serious implications on project timelines - costing time and money - as the
product will need to be fixed or replaced and retested.
Reducing risk of factory test failure
Independent, third-party verification -
such as that provided through Eurovent Certified Performance programmes - helps
to ensure that performance data used at the design and procurement stage is
both reliable and comparable.
Eurovent Certified Performance programmes
use state of the art evaluation protocols including laboratory tests, factory
audits, selection software certification and evaluation of all submitted data
(including data sheets and marketing materials) to ensure the data declared is
accurate, verified and certified against recognised standards and real-world
requirements.
In addition, Eurovent certified IT cooling units
and Very High Temperature Process Chillers enter a surveillance process which
includes regular factory audits, laboratory tests and software checks. This ensures
the products, and their selection software, remain accurate and compliant with
certified data – a critical step in guaranteeing product performance.
For data centre operators, this provides:
- Confidence that equipment performs as stated
- Greater transparency during equipment selection
- Trust in software selection tools as they have also been certified
- A level playing field when comparing different certified solutions.
- Certified performance data supports better decision-making early in the project lifecycle, reducing the likelihood of underperformance later.
Safeguarding the witness test
Certification’s role doesn’t stop there. It
can help give assurance that a certified manufacturer’s in-house testing
facilities deliver accurate factory witness test results. In certain Eurovent Certification
programmes such as its Chillers and Heat Pump programme (LCP-HP) and its IT
Cooling Unit programme (ITCU), Eurovent Certification allows manufacturers to
use their own laboratories for Eurovent surveillance tests under what is known
as the Participant Laboratory option. This option is available only when
the manufacturer’s laboratory meets all requirements of the relevant test
standards and methods indicated in programme-specific TCR (technical
certification rules) documents.
For surveillance purposes, a certain number
of units (determined by the programme rules) is selected for testing. Some of
these tests may be conducted in the manufacturer’s laboratory, but always by an
accredited independent partner laboratory assigned to the tests by Eurovent
Certification. The partner laboratory must use its own calibrated measuring
equipment rather than the devices available in the manufacturer’s laboratory
and must follow the programme rules and applicable standards.
During these tests, Eurovent Certification
may also request manufacturers to take measurements with their own devices across
selected tests and share these results. Eurovent Certification then performs an
internal comparison between the manufacturer’s measurements and those of the
independent laboratory to verify that any deviations remain within the
permissible limits defined by the programme-specific TCR document and based on
the applicable standards. If deviations fall outside the allowable range, Eurovent
Certification requires a root cause analysis and, where necessary, corrective
actions.
Eurovent Certification also issues an
Approval of Compliance document to manufacturer laboratories approved to
conduct Eurovent surveillance tests. While this document is not a formal
accreditation or certification of the participant’s laboratory, it confirms
that the laboratory meets the relevant standards, demonstrates compliant
measurement accuracy, and is therefore approved for Eurovent tests.
For specifiers and data centre operators
this provides a triple layer of assurance. Certified data guarantees the
truthfulness of the manufacturer’s performance claims, while the factory
witness test - in a laboratory with test accuracy verified by Eurovent
Certification - confirms that the actual delivered unit meets those claims at
the project’s critical operating points.
Conclusion: from assumptions to assurance
As data centres continue to grow in scale,
density and criticality, the tolerance for uncertainty in cooling system
performance continues to shrink. HVAC equipment is no longer selected solely on
the basis of nominal capacity or compliance with a written specification; it
must deliver proven, repeatable performance under real operating conditions,
from day one and throughout its lifecycle.
A robust supply process, underpinned by
accurate performance data and validated through factory witness testing, is
central to achieving this. If the manufacturers laboratory has also had its test
accuracy independently validated, risk of data deviations can be further reduced.
However, factory testing alone cannot compensate for unverified declared
performance data at the design and procurement stage. If theoretical performance
assumptions are incorrect, the risk of failed factory witness tests, design
changes, project delays and spiralling costs increases.
This is why Eurovent Certified Performance
is essential for data centre cooling systems. By independently verifying that manufacturers
declared performance data is accurate, comparable and repeatable, Eurovent
Certification provides a trusted foundation for system design and equipment
selection. For operators and specifiers, it reduces uncertainty early in the
project lifecycle, supports fair comparison of solutions, and lowers the risk
of unexpected outcomes later.
Eurovent Certification provides dedicated
certification programmes for data centre cooling equipment including its IT
Cooling Unit (ITCU) programme (CRAC/CRAH/Hybrid and rear door units) and its Chillers and
Heat Pump (LCP-HP) programme which certifies Very High Temperature Process
Chillers with or without free cooling. Eurovent Certification also offers
schemes for the full cooling infrastructure including cooling towers, heat
exchangers, air handling units and evaporative cooling.
Discover
more at www.eurovent-certification.com
Cloud & AI Infrastructure
DevOps Live
Cloud & Cyber Security Expo
Big Data & AI World
Data Centre World